Verdict

Jordan is right

Over-hanging preference is the established structural standard

The dispute

Should toilet roll hang over or under?

Morgan v Jordan

While Morgan correctly identifies that 'under' offers a tidier aesthetic and prevents excessive unspooling, the 'over' orientation is functionally superior as it keeps the paper clear of the wall and allows for easier one-handed operation. The historical precedent of the original design patent provides a definitive, albeit pedantic, tie-breaker in favor of Jordan.

Morgan may take comfort in the fact that their method is objectively superior for preventing feline-assisted bathroom destruction.